“Patients are now receiving more proactive, better planned care in line with their wishes."
Dr AM, GP Wareham Surgery
PIG -Early Identification Tool
Identifying patients’ decline earlier enabling more proactive care.
The GSF Proactive Identification Guidance (formerly known as the Prognostic Indicator Guidance) was developed in 2004 to enable GPs and other clinicians to improve earlier identification of patients on the last year or so of life.
It is a key tool used within the Gold Standards Framework (GSF) Quality Improvements Training Programmes to support earlier identification of patients, enabling better assessment of their needs and planning care in line with their needs and wishes.
This PIG guidance aims to clarify the triggers that help to identify patients earlier, in order that care can be better planned, more proactive, anticipate patients’ needs and take into account their own wishes following a discussion of their choices and preferences (advance care planning discussion).
These patients should be included on a supportive/palliative care register in their GP practice, care home or hospital and in many areas these patients are included on a locality register (digital shared information record) or EpaCCS.
PIG is free to use, but please register with us if you plan to use it in practice, and inform us of how you are using it .
NICE 2019 Guidance on End of Life Care Service Delivery see here
and GMC Guidance definition here
End of life care includes the care and support given in the final weeks and months of life, and the planning and preparation for this. For some conditions, this could be months or years.
This includes people with:
• advanced, progressive, incurable conditions
• general frailty and coexisting conditions that mean they are at increased risk of dying within the next 12 months
• existing conditions if they are at risk of dying from a sudden acute crisis in their condition
• life-threatening acute conditions caused by sudden catastrophic events.
(This does not cover the clinical care of adults who are expected to die within a few hours or days. For advice on this, see the NICE guideline on care of dying adults in the last days of life)
Definition of End of Life Care UK
Predicting needs rather than exact prognostication
PIG is more about meeting needs than giving defined timescales. The focus is on anticipating patients’ likely needs so that the right care can be provided at the right time. This is related to helping people live well in the time remaining, rather than exact prognostication and leads to better proactive care in alignment with preferences.
Clinical teams undertaking GSF in their respective settings (GP Practices, care homes, hospitals etc) use PIG firstly to identify patients earlier, then a process of better assessment and planning, which includes use the Needs-based Coding to clarify their different needs with specific actions/ tasks for each stage, to enable better proactive coordinated care.
Benefits to patients and carers of early identification
Encourages open, honest conversations.
Enables patients to be more in control- puts patients in the driving seat.
Helps provide clarity and highlights patient choices.
Gives the opportunity to express wishes and preferences for the future to professionals and family.
Earlier planning to provide information for patients and families so that they can set goals, priorities and expectations of care.
To help patients develop insight into their dying.
Other benefits include more time to plan ahead, to get their ‘house in order’ and to discuss deeper or spiritual issues.
Benefits to health and social care teams of early identification
Proactive planning rather than reactive crisis intervention.
To assist clinicians in decision making.
More coordinated care and improved communication.
Better use of existing resources and decreasing unwanted interventions or hospital admissions.
For policy making regarding appropriate use and allocation of resources and support services.
To provide a common language for health care and social care professionals involved in end of life care in different settings.
Potential disadvantages of early identification
Patients may only hear the bad news, especially if told in an insensitive way.
Some patients may not want to discuss this and refuse further discussion i.e., important only that they are OFFERED the ACP discussion.
Initial distress, though in the long term, leading to more realistic hope.
Difficulty coping with a changed reality and apparent hopelessness.
Protecting family or patient or ‘collusion of silence’.
What PIG is
PIG provides supporting evidence to help clinicians anticipate whether a patient may be declining and in their final years, months or weeks of life and thereby need extra supportive care.
A guidance based on best available evidence from experts in each of their fields on indicators of decline in each condition.
It is more of an ‘insurance ‘ approach- what would we need to get prepared if this person was nearing the end of life- not predicting with certainly that they are.
What PIG is not
PIG is not a means of exact prognostication of time remaining to a patient.
PIG is not an answer to the question ‘How long have I got?’
It is not a clarification to help judge the value of a treatment.
Earlier identification through use of PIG should lead to additional active supportive care, and not to denying patients any treatment or intervention or a DNACPR discussion.
How to use PIG
Three triggers that suggest that patients are declining, as used in GSF:
Surprise Question: ‘Would you be surprised if this patient were to die in the next few months, weeks, days?’
General indicators of decline – deterioration, increasing need or choice for no further active care.
Specific clinical indicators related to certain conditions.
Once identified and included on the register, such patients may be able to receive additional proactive support, leading to better co-ordinated care reflecting their preferences.
This is in line with current thinking on shared decision-making processes and the importance of integrating advance care planning discussions into delivery of care. It is based on consideration of people’s needs rather than exact timescales, acknowledging that people need different things at different times.
Earlier recognition of possible illness trajectories means their needs can be better anticipated and addressed.
It is recommended that Advance Care Planning discussions are offered to all as early as possible before further decline, including all suggested here, those in care homes or with COVID.
See Advance Care Planning here
Examples of the the three main illness trajectories
Use of GSF Needs Based Coding
Once patients have been identified they have a needs assessment. Needs based coding is used to highlight the level of need by using the red, amber, green (RAG) colour coding system. Red colour coding signifies last days of life, amber – deteriorating, green – decline/ unstable/ advanced disease.
Note - although there is an obvious correlation with timescales and progression of the disease trajectory, this needs-based coding relates to changing needs at different stages to ensure that the patients’ needs are anticipated and met - as in the GSF Programmes, the right person receives the right care at the right time in the right place - every time
How PIG is used...
In Primary Care
An estimated 1% of the population dies each year; about 20 patients per GP (with an average list size of 2000). This guidance supports early identification by the practice team to consider whether they could be included on the GPs’ Palliative Care/QOF/GSF register and need additional active supportive or palliative care.
Once included they are discussed at regular MDT discussions, preferably monthly but at minimum 3 monthly.
This is ‘ bronze’ level GSF, mainstreamed to all UK GP practices since 2004. In addition, since 2010, many practices have undertaken the next level GSF Silver or Gold, leading to practice accreditation.
Examples of good practice include;
GSF accredited practices identifying 50-90 % of their practice patients who die
Significant increases in GP practices identifying their patients, from an average of 25% to above 50%
Initiating Advance Care Planning discussions (ACP) on average 68% the range across the 17 practices (37% - 100%)
In Care Homes
It is estimated that 80% of nursing care home residents will be in their final year of life. Residents will have their needs assessed and coded on admission and all residents will have had an initial ACP discussion.
Examples of good practice include;
Identifying and needs-based coding all residents in GSF accredited care homes
In Other Settings
PIG is also used in other settings such as hospices, domiciliary care, prisons, etc.
Research would suggest that at any one time 30% of acute hospital inpatients will be in their final year of life (Clarke 2014). However, few hospitals are currently identifying that proportion of patients as being in their final year of life.
Hospital teams using GSF however do attain this kind of proportion of early identification of patients, who are then discussed at board rounds/MDT meetings regularly and coded according to needs and phase of illness and an ACP discussion will be initiated.
Examples of good practice include;
London Hospital Example (see diagram below) identifying 33% of their 48,000 patients as being in the last year of life ie 16,000 patients- and only 1300 (12%) of these patients are seen by specialist palliative care team ie 88% are under the care of generalists in hospital. GSF helps enable these generalists who give the majority of the care .
GSF Accredited Acute Hospitals on average identifying 34% patients on their wards
Community hospitals increasing identification rates from 34% to over 60% in some cases
Placeholder video for Pete Nightingale
Dr Pete Nightingale, Lancaster GP describes how he uses the GSF PIG in his practice and uses the needs-based coding to prioritise people and better meet their needs (see below).
2021 Revision and Expert Advisory Group
Note the PIG is currently being revised in collaboration with Hospice UK - see the 2021 edition out later this year.